Somberly you proclaim your judgement in favor of the tortoiseshells. The cats are at first quite surprised, judging by their cute little paying-attention faces, but then, after greater introspection, come around to your way of seeing things. A subtle but profound change to cat society comes about because of your ruling, and the new cats in charge invite you onto their Supurreme Court where you become of the most important jurors of your time. You never quite figure out what's going on with the smell-based argument thing, though, but you seem to do ok without that.